In Victoria, “reasonably clean” means clean by average community standards: not spotless or pristine, and not terribly messy, but somewhere in the middle. It is measured against the condition the property was in when you moved in, as shown in your condition report and photos, and it takes fair wear and tear into account.
Where the rule comes from
The Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (Vic) requires renters to keep the property reasonably clean during the tenancy and, when they leave, to hand it back reasonably clean and in the same condition as when they moved in, allowing for fair wear and tear. The Act does not spell out what that looks like in practice, so the Director of Consumer Affairs Victoria has issued Guideline 2: Cleanliness. VCAT must have regard to that guideline when it decides a dispute about cleanliness.
The practical test
The guideline offers a useful rule of thumb: a surface is generally reasonably clean if it is free from marks, dirt, cobwebs, stains and dust, and wiping it again would not make it any cleaner. If a second wipe of the benchtop changes nothing, you have reached the standard for that surface.
The standard also depends on the nature, age and circumstances of the property. A 1970s unit with original laminate is not judged as though it were a new build. Stains that have soaked into old grout over decades are a different matter from fresh food splatter on the cooktop.
What reasonably clean looks like, area by area
| Area | Expected standard (summarised from CAV’s guideline) |
|---|---|
| Oven, stove, rangehood | Free of oil, grease and food stains |
| Dishwasher | Free of grease, grime, food scraps and strong odours |
| Bathroom fixtures | Baths, showers, toilets, sinks and vanities free of dirt, stains, soap scum and mould caused by the renter |
| Mirrors | Free of dust, marks and smears |
| Walls and skirtings | Reasonably free of scuffs, fingerprints and dust |
| Floors | Washed and free of dirt, dust and stains |
| Carpets | Free of pet hair, stains and strong odours such as urine |
| Windows and sills | Free of marks and dust, including the outside of ground-floor windows |
| Curtains and blinds | Free of dust and stains |
| Cupboards | Emptied and free of dust and dirt |
| Heating ducts, exhaust fans | Clean and free of dust |
| Outside | Rubbish removed, garden beds weeded, lawns mowed unless that is the rental provider’s job, shed or garage emptied |
For a working list you can tick off on cleaning day, use our end of lease cleaning checklist.
What it does not mean
Better than when you moved in
The guideline summarises VCAT decisions holding that reasonably clean does not mean a condition superior to the one recorded in the condition report. If the oven was greasy when you arrived and the report says so, you are not expected to hand it back brand new. Equally, the fact that the property is in a lesser state than at the start does not automatically mean you owe compensation, because fair wear and tear is allowed for.
Fixing the building
The guideline separates mould or damp caused by a renter not taking care from mould or damp caused by, or related to, the building itself. Mould from a leaking roof or failed waterproofing is not a cleaning failure on your part. Report building problems in writing as soon as you notice them so there is a record.
Climbing to dangerous heights
Renters are not expected to reach ceiling fans where access may be dangerous, and the guideline notes that cleaning at heights may often be considered maintenance, which is the rental provider’s responsibility. Use an extendable duster for what you can reach from the floor.
What falls short
The guideline lists examples VCAT has treated as below the standard. Cobwebs, dusty walls and dirty kitchen appliances are among them, as are overgrown garden beds and personal belongings left behind. More extreme examples include rats or mice on the premises and hoarded goods that create a fire or safety risk.
Reasonably clean versus professional standard
Cleaning to a professional standard is a higher bar than reasonably clean, and for agreements made on or after 29 March 2021 a rental provider can only require it in limited situations under regulation 12 of the Residential Tenancies Regulations 2021:
- the property was professionally cleaned immediately before your tenancy started and you were told so, or
- professional cleaning is needed to restore the property to its starting condition, having regard to the condition report and allowing for fair wear and tear.
CAV’s examples of the second situation include lingering smoke or pet odours, wine or urine stains in carpet, grease or soot on walls or ceilings, and soap scum build-up in the bath or shower. Older agreements made before 29 March 2021 can be different, so check your own agreement. Carpets are covered in detail in do you have to steam clean carpets when you move out.
How to show you met the standard
- Keep your entry condition report, which CAV says both parties must hold until the end of the agreement. CAV’s condition reports page explains how it is used.
- Take dated photos after you finish, matching the angles of the entry photos.
- Attend the final inspection, or make sure you were offered a reasonable opportunity to.
- Keep receipts for anything you had professionally cleaned.
Our guide to getting your bond back covers what happens if the rental provider disagrees.
Meeting the standard without the guesswork
Reasonably clean is a judgement call, and it helps to have someone who cleans to that standard every day. If you would rather not judge it yourself, Prime Cleaners Melbourne can take the job on as an end of lease clean, with a free written quote first.
Quick answers
Is reasonably clean the same as the condition on move-in day?
Broadly, you must leave the property reasonably clean and in the same condition as when you moved in, taking fair wear and tear into account. The condition report is the record VCAT relies on to judge the starting condition, so its notes and photos matter.